Congratulations Colonel Jeffrey Nance. Your verdict yesterday allowing Bowe Bergdahl to walk away without serving a single day in prison is yet another victory for anti-military leftists and a blow to the Constitution that you, personally, swore to support and defend against all enemies, foreign and domestic. Foreign and domestic. You’ve continued the assault on the Pentagon by those who see our military as a social engineering petri dish and not an institution of lethal firepower and defense. You’ve sided with those who want to attack the martial values and Judeo-Christian ethic that is the foundation of military service. And, simultaneously, you’ve created a new icon for the Antifa, Soros, anti-American movement, that will no doubt revel in the attention he’ll receive.

I don’t know you, Colonel Nance, I haven’t read your biography, but I’m guessing you’ve never commanded men and women in combat. For if you had, you’d understand the outraged reaction of our nation and your peers across the Department of Defense. If you had ever commanded, you would have known better. Instead, you let a confessed deserter, one of the most highly-profiled in decades, walk away with only a dishonorable discharge, a reduction in rank and a $10,000 fine. He abandoned his fellow soldiers during a time of war yet he get’s off with a virtual slap on the wrist. How, on Earth, could you come to that conclusion? What were you thinking? He pled guilty and you let him go.

Now, your decision will send unnecessary shockwaves throughout the U.S. military. You’ve set an undeniable precedent that current and future commanders will have to grapple with. As if they don’t already have enough to deal with as America faces down Islamic evil worldwide, confronts the rapidly emerging nuclear threat in North Korea, and deals with the ever-present tensions with fellow superpowers Russia and China. You’ve also done an incredible disservice to those men who died or were maimed trying to find Bergdahl. For example, Sergeant First Class Mark Allen, who was paralyzed and lost the ability to talk or take care of himself while searching for Bergdahl. Bergdahl gets to walk but Sgt. Allen doesn’t. The sergeant avoids a life sentence but the families of those tasked with finding him, don’t.

As a retired officer and former commander in the U.S. Air Force, I shudder to contemplate the consequences your decision will have. You have created a precedent that directly contradicts a units’ morale, order, and discipline. You have removed accountability from the leadership tool box. Now, when a disgruntled airman wants to walk away from his duties, he has a living, breathing example. And, a freed one. Now, when a sailor is on liberty in a foreign port of call, he can terminate his service without severe repercussions.

You also freed a deserter that will now cash in on his notoriety. Bergdahl will, no doubt, lock up a future book deal, a speaking career, possibly a reality show, maybe even a movie. Even more incentive for members of our military to look to do the same, and more challenges and headaches for our military leaders at a time when they don’t need any additional problems or casualties.

From this commander’s view, the Bergdahl desertion has been handled absolutely horribly. First, by the Barack Obama administration agreeing to transfer five high-value combatant detainees (the “Taliban Five”) for the Army sergeant and staging a Rose Garden ceremony to celebrate it. Susan Rice, yes that Susan Rice, called Bergdahl’s service “honorable.” Telling, that the Obama administration would release the enemy captured on the battlefield and consider a soldier leaving his comrades’ behind during combat to join the enemy “honorable.” Only in their “America last” thinking could that ever be the case.

You have significantly compounded the problem Colonel Nance. You’ve singlehandedly contradicted U.S. military law and tradition. In doing so, you have forever altered how our military organizations will be commanded and traitors prosecuted.. You’ve joined the ranks of those who’ve declared war on our armed services.. This commander doesn’t agree or appreciate it. I’m sure thousands currently serving feel precisely the same.

Previous articleThe Michigan Review Nov 1. 2017
Next article“What Difference Does It Make”?
Lieutenant Colonel Robert "Buzz" Patterson, United States Air Force (Retired), is a military combat pilot, distinguished White House military aide, bestselling author, and popular conservative public speaker. Among Patterson’s literary efforts include two New York Times best sellers, Dereliction of Duty and Reckless Disregard. His most recent books include War Crimes and Conduct Unbecoming. Patterson served 20 years as a pilot on active duty in the United States Air Force and saw tours of duty world-wide including combat operations in Grenada, Bosnia, the Persian Gulf, Somalia, Rwanda, and Haiti. From 1996 to 1998, Colonel Patterson was Military Aide to President Bill Clinton. During that time, he served at the right hand of President and Mrs. Hillary Clinton and was responsible for the President's Emergency Satchel, otherwise known as the "Nuclear Football," the black bag with the nation's nuclear capability that accompanies the president at all times. As such, Patterson had an office and a bedroom in the White House and accompanied the First Family at all times. In addition, Colonel Patterson was operational commander for all military units assigned to the White House, which included Air Force One, Marine One, Camp David, and the White House Transportation Agency. Patterson was born in Chapel Hill, North Carolina. He is a Distinguished Graduate from the Air Command and Staff College; he has his Bachelor's Degree in Political Science from Virginia Tech University and a Master's in Business Administration from Webster University in St. Louis, Missouri. He, his wife and their three children currently reside in California. Facebook @ Buzz Patterson Twitter @ BuzzPatterson


  1. Thank you for your words, Buzz. I 100% agree with everything you said. Col. Nance will forever be known as the Judge who opened the flood gates for deserters.
    Bergdahl should have been met with shackles and chains on his arrival back home and then thrown into a deep dark hole to be never seen or heard from again.

  2. I have to wonder if Private Slovick is rolling over in his grave. Executed based on a controversial conviction for treason, today he might get a medal. Thank you, Colonel, for putting this reprehensible decision in perspective. Reduction in rank? Dishonorable discharge? He’ll have a million dollars (perhaps a lot more) in his pocket by 1 Dec. And he’ll be crying all the way to the bank.

  3. I sincerely Thank you Lieutenant Colonel “Buzz” Patterson for your great, almost-too-soft letter to the Obama-tronic “judge” who has so enriched Bergdahl, and has so rewarded Bergdahl’s traitorousness!

    • I have a feeling that this was a show trial from the beginning. They were never going to imprison Obama’s pet Islamo-sympathetic deserter. This stinks of the other miscarriage of justice when Comey let Hillary off the hook after delineating all her crimes!

  4. I’m so disgusted with Nance. Bergdahl deserved to hang in my book. There is a sailer in prison for taking a photo on a submarine for his own keepsake! This deserter who not only abandoned his fellow soldiers in time of war, but actually SOUGHT OUT the enemy, gets a slap on the wrist. Are there no standards even in the military anymore? I made the same observation as the Colonel…this sets a terrible precedent! Bergdahl belongs in prison…and Nance belongs in the cell next to his.

  5. Well stated Lt Col “Buzz” Patterson. The adjudication of the UCMJ is nothing to be taken lightly, and COL Nance has definitely fallen short on his responsibilities and duties. Good order and discipline are key ingredients to the success of any organization across the DoD and that ingredient has been “watered down” by this judge. COL Nance’s decision to not imprison Bowe Bergdahl will affect every Commanding Officer, Senior Enlisted Leader and Junior Leader for decades to come when they hold service members accountable for acts of misconduct. Bowe Bergdahl violated one of the most basic articles of conduct we learn and follow upon entering service which is General Order #1, and COL Nance should be held accountable for violating the spirit of General Order #2. Much respect to you sir and continue to Aim High……CSM (R) West, U.S. Army

  6. My heart sank and broke into tiny pieces with this Judge’s decision. I’m sure he voted for Obama twice and Hillary last year. What else could explain this complete INSANITY and yes…DERELICTION OF DUTY to the Military?? I PRAY Bergdahl gets NO book deal, movie deal, etc., and meets a fate on the “outside” worthy of his service.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here